1
When it comes to savoring the freshest seafood, Nantucket stands as a coastal gem brimming with culinary delights. Whether you’re a visitor seeking an authentic taste of the island’s maritime heritage or a local looking for your next favorite spot, this guide will introduce you to the best seafood restaurants in Nantucket. These must-visit eateries offer dishes that perfectly capture the island’s coastal charm.
The Nautilus: A Fusion of Creativity and Freshness
Located in the heart of downtown Nantucket, The Nautilus is a seafood lover’s paradise. Known for its innovative menu, this restaurant blends Asian-inspired flavors with traditional New England seafood staples. The crudo dishes, including the locally caught scallops, are a highlight. Don’t miss their signature dish: the “Nautilus Shellfish Tower,” a stunning array of oysters, clams, shrimp, and lobster.
Straight Wharf Fish: A Reinvented Classic
Formerly known as The Clam Shack, Straight Wharf Fish has become a new favorite for seafood enthusiasts. With its focus on simplicity and freshness, this restaurant offers a menu that highlights the best local catches. Signature dishes include their fried clam rolls and classic lobster dinners. Its casual ambiance makes it an excellent choice for a relaxed meal by the waterfront.
Straight Wharf Restaurant: Elegance by the Waterfront
A Nantucket institution, Straight Wharf Restaurant offers a fine dining experience with spectacular harbor views. The menu emphasizes seasonality and local ingredients, featuring dishes like grilled swordfish and clam bake-inspired creations. Pair your meal with one of their carefully curated wines for a truly memorable evening.
Cru: The Ultimate Raw Bar Experience
If you’re a fan of oysters, Cru is the place to be. This chic waterfront restaurant boasts one of the island’s best raw bars. From briny local oysters to lobster rolls that overflow with sweet, tender meat, Cru’s offerings are a celebration of Nantucket’s rich seafood culture. Enjoy your meal while soaking in views of the bustling marina.
Sayle’s Seafood: Casual Dining with a Local Touch
For a more laid-back experience, head to Sayle’s Seafood, a beloved spot for fresh seafood to go. Known for its clam chowder and fried seafood platters, Sayle’s also offers steamed lobsters and an impressive selection of shellfish. It’s perfect for a casual beach picnic or a cozy dinner at home.
The Chanticleer: A Garden Oasis with Coastal Flavors
Nestled in the charming village of Siasconset, The Chanticleer offers an enchanting dining experience. Known for its romantic garden setting, the restaurant’s menu features seafood dishes like pan-seared halibut and Nantucket bay scallops. The emphasis on local ingredients ensures every bite reflects the island’s unique flavors.
Millie’s: Coastal Comfort Food
Situated in Madaket, Millie’s combines a relaxed atmosphere with a menu packed with coastal favorites. Known for their fish tacos and lobster quesadillas, Millie’s puts a creative twist on classic dishes. After a satisfying meal, enjoy the stunning sunset views that Madaket is famous for.
Oran Mor Bistro: Sophistication Meets Sustainability
For a refined dining experience, Oran Mor Bistro is a must-visit. This cozy yet sophisticated restaurant specializes in sustainably sourced seafood. Highlights include the seared Nantucket fluke and lobster risotto. The intimate setting and impeccable service make Oran Mor perfect for special occasions.
Tips for Enjoying Nantucket’s Seafood Scene
- Make Reservations: Nantucket’s top seafood restaurants fill up quickly, especially during the summer season.
- Ask About Specials: Many restaurants offer daily specials featuring the freshest catches.
- Explore Beyond the Menu: Don’t hesitate to ask your server for recommendations or off-menu items.
- Pair with Local Drinks: Complement your meal with Nantucket’s craft beers or a glass of crisp white wine.
Final Thoughts
Nantucket’s seafood scene is a testament to the island’s vibrant coastal culture. From elegant waterfront dining to casual spots perfect for a quick bite, these restaurants promise an unforgettable culinary experience. So, whether you’re indulging in a luxurious shellfish tower or savoring a simple bowl of clam chowder, each dish tells a story of the sea’s bounty and the island’s charm.
Discover the best seafood restaurants in Nantucket. From elegant dining to casual spots, explore must-visit places offering fresh, local seafood.Inbox