1
Discover where the locals eat in Nantucket! From hidden bistros to food trucks and seafood shacks, explore the island’s best-kept dining secrets.
Nantucket may be famous for its picturesque scenery and seaside charm, but its vibrant food scene is one of the island’s best-kept secrets. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a seasoned traveler, uncovering local dining secrets is the key to experiencing Nantucket like a native. From hidden bistros to bustling food trucks, here’s where the locals eat in Nantucket.
Discover Hidden Gems in Nantucket
Exploring Nantucket’s dining scene means stepping off the beaten path to find hidden gems beloved by locals. These tucked-away treasures offer everything from fresh seafood to hearty comfort foods.
1. The Proprietors Bar & Table Known for its inventive small plates and globally inspired menu, The Proprietors Bar & Table is a local favorite. With a cozy, rustic ambiance, it’s the perfect spot for sharing dishes with friends or enjoying a relaxed date night.
2. Black-Eyed Susan’s For an authentic Nantucket breakfast, locals flock to Black-Eyed Susan’s. This unassuming eatery is renowned for its savory omelets, fluffy pancakes, and homemade hash browns. Be prepared to wait—it’s worth it!
Food Trucks: Quick and Delicious Options
If you’re on the go, Nantucket’s food trucks provide quick, tasty bites without sacrificing quality. These mobile eateries are a favorite among locals for their affordability and flavor.
3. Sushi Sean 11:11 Serving up some of the freshest sushi on the island, Sushi Sean 11:11 is a must-try for seafood lovers. Locals rave about the spicy tuna rolls and fresh poke bowls.
Cozy Cafés and Bakeries
For those who prefer a leisurely brunch or afternoon coffee, Nantucket’s cafés and bakeries do not disappoint. Locals frequent these spots for pastries, sandwiches, and artisan coffee.
4. Lemon Press This charming café offers a farm-to-table experience with a health-conscious twist. From avocado toast to nutrient-packed smoothies, Lemon Press is ideal for a wholesome start to your day.
5. Wicked Island Bakery Known for its mouthwatering pastries and decadent cinnamon rolls, Wicked Island Bakery is a haven for those with a sweet tooth. Be sure to grab a box of treats to go!
Seafood Shacks and Waterfront Dining
No trip to Nantucket is complete without sampling its world-famous seafood. Locals know the best places to savor lobster rolls and clam chowder.
6. Sayle’s Seafood A hidden gem for takeout, Sayle’s Seafood serves up some of the best fried clams and lobster rolls on the island. Pack a picnic and enjoy your meal by the water.
7. Cru For a more upscale experience, Cru offers breathtaking harbor views and a raw bar featuring oysters and local shellfish. It’s a favorite for celebrations and sunset dining.
Farm-to-Table Dining Experiences
Nantucket’s farm-to-table movement has gained popularity, and several restaurants now focus on using fresh, local ingredients.
8. The Chanticleer Tucked away in the charming Siasconset area, The Chanticleer offers a romantic setting and a menu highlighting local produce and seafood. It’s a hidden treasure perfect for special occasions.
Experience Nantucket Like a Local
Discovering where the locals eat in Nantucket reveals more than just delicious meals—it offers a glimpse into the island’s culture and community. From hidden bistros to beloved food trucks, these dining spots highlight the flavors and traditions that make Nantucket unique.
So next time you visit, step off the tourist trail and explore these local dining secrets. You’ll leave with a full stomach and a deeper appreciation for Nantucket’s culinary charm.