Summer on Nantucket Island is a feast for the senses. As the warm sun sets over pristine beaches and the salty sea breeze fills the air, the island’s dining scene bursts to life with fresh, seasonal flavors. From waterfront seafood shacks to upscale restaurants, Nantucket’s eateries offer a diverse array of culinary delights that capture the essence of summer. Whether you’re craving just-caught lobster or a refreshing cocktail, this guide will take you on a tour of the island’s must-visit dining spots this summer.
Waterfront Gems
No summer dining experience on Nantucket is complete without a meal by the water. Restaurants like Cru, located on the harbor, offer breathtaking views alongside their acclaimed seafood dishes. Their raw bar, featuring oysters, littlenecks, and shrimp cocktail, is the perfect way to start a summer evening. Don’t miss their lobster roll, served warm with butter or chilled with mayo—a quintessential Nantucket treat.
For a more refined waterfront experience, visit Brant Point Grill, located at the White Elephant Hotel. Known for its elegant setting and exceptional cuisine, Brant Point Grill offers an array of summer classics like grilled swordfish, lobster bisque, and their signature lobster mac and cheese. Pair your meal with a crisp glass of rosé while taking in the stunning harbor views.
Seasonal Farm-to-Table Dining
Summer is the season when Nantucket’s farms shine, and many restaurants proudly showcase the island’s locally sourced ingredients. The Proprietors Bar & Table is a standout, featuring creative dishes that highlight fresh produce, herbs, and seafood. Their ever-changing menu offers a mix of global flavors with a New England twist, making every visit a unique culinary adventure.
Another farm-to-table favorite is Ventuno, an Italian-inspired eatery nestled in the heart of town. Using ingredients straight from Nantucket’s farms, Ventuno serves handmade pasta and vibrant vegetable dishes that epitomize the freshness of summer.
Casual Beachside Bites
If you’re spending the day at the beach, Nantucket’s casual dining options make it easy to grab a delicious meal without straying too far from the shore. Sandbar at Jetties Beach is a quintessential summer spot, offering everything from fish tacos to frozen cocktails. It’s the ideal place to relax with friends and watch the sunset.
For a quick and satisfying lunch, visit Straight Wharf Fish Market, where you can pick up a lobster roll, clam chowder, or even a picnic-ready seafood platter. With its prime location and fresh, simple menu, it’s a go-to for beachgoers.
Sweet Summer Treats
No summer day on Nantucket is complete without indulging in something sweet. The Juice Bar, located downtown, is famous for its homemade ice cream and waffle cones made fresh to order. Flavors range from classic chocolate to more adventurous options like rum raisin or cranberry chip.
For a lighter treat, stop by Born & Bread, a local bakery offering freshly baked pastries, cookies, and fruit tarts. Their lemon squares and seasonal berry pies are summer perfection.
Cocktails and Nightlife
As the sun sets, Nantucket’s vibrant nightlife takes over. Enjoy a handcrafted cocktail at The Pearl, where the bartenders are known for their creative takes on summer classics like mojitos and margaritas. Or head to The Chicken Box, a local institution, for live music, cold beers, and a lively crowd that’s always ready to dance.
For a more laid-back evening, visit Cisco Brewers, where you can sip on locally brewed beer, wine, or spirits in an outdoor setting complete with food trucks and live music. It’s a must-visit spot for summer evenings on the island.
Another standout is The Gaslight, a live music venue and restaurant that combines great food with an energetic atmosphere. Known for its expertly crafted cocktails and rotating lineup of talented musicians, The Gaslight is the perfect place to enjoy a summer night out with friends.
Planning Your Summer Food Tour
With its array of seasonal eateries, Nantucket is a culinary paradise in the summer months. To make the most of your dining experiences, be sure to book reservations well in advance for popular spots, as tables fill up quickly during peak season. And don’t forget to explore the island’s farmers’ markets and food festivals for even more ways to savor the flavors of summer.
Whether you’re dining on freshly shucked oysters by the harbor or enjoying a casual meal on the beach, Nantucket’s summer dining scene offers something for everyone. Let the island’s fresh ingredients and coastal charm inspire your next culinary adventure.
