16
About The Brotherhood of Thieves
Established in 1972, The Brotherhood of Thieves is a Nantucket icon, steeped in history and hospitality. Housed in an 1840s whaling bar, this restaurant offers a warm and rustic atmosphere with exposed beams, brick walls, and a sense of timeless charm.
In 2021, the Brotherhood expanded to include three additional concepts:
- The Beer Garden Patio: A lively outdoor space perfect for casual dining.
- The Notch Whiskey Bar: An upscale venue featuring curated whiskey flights and craft cocktails.
- Cisco Kitchen & Bar: A modern take on coastal dining with fresh, innovative flavors.
Dining Highlights
- Signature Dishes:
- Lobster Roll: Fresh, succulent lobster meat served on a toasted bun.
- Brotherhood Burger: A classic burger with customizable toppings to suit your taste.
- Fish and Chips: Crispy, golden-fried fish paired with hand-cut fries and coleslaw.
- Craft Beers and Cocktails:
Choose from a rotating selection of local craft beers on tap, as well as expertly mixed cocktails and a curated wine list. - Diverse Dining Experiences:
Whether you’re dining in the historic pub downstairs, enjoying a meal in the Cisco Kitchen upstairs, relaxing in the beer garden, or indulging at the Notch Whiskey Bar, there’s a perfect space for every mood.
Why Choose The Brotherhood of Thieves?
- Historical Ambiance: Enjoy a meal in a space rich with Nantucket’s whaling history.
- Variety of Options: From casual to upscale, there’s a dining area and menu to suit any occasion.
- Locally Sourced Ingredients: Many dishes are prepared using fresh, local ingredients, ensuring quality and flavor.
Getting There
Located at 23 Broad Street, The Brotherhood of Thieves is centrally situated in downtown Nantucket, just steps from the island’s top attractions. Street parking is available, but spots fill quickly during peak hours.
Insider Tip:
For a lively evening, head to the beer garden during the summer months. To explore the whiskey bar’s curated selection, visit during the quieter midweek evenings for a more intimate experience.
