11
Nantucket, a charming island off the coast of Massachusetts, is famous for its cobblestone streets, breathtaking beaches, and historic whaling past. But for food lovers, it's a paradise of fresh seafood, farm-to-table delights, and artisanal treats waiting to be discovered. Whether you're visiting for a weekend or a few days longer, this itinerary will guide you through the best flavors Nantucket has to offer.
Day 1: A Seafood Lover’s Dream
Breakfast: Freshly Baked Goodness at Born & Bread
Kickstart your foodie adventure with a visit to Born & Bread, a beloved local bakery known for its flaky croissants, buttery scones, and house-made quiches. Pair it with a cup of locally brewed coffee for the perfect morning start.
Lunch: Lobster Rolls at Sayle’s Seafood
No trip to Nantucket is complete without indulging in a lobster roll. Head over to Sayle’s Seafood, a laid-back seafood shack that serves one of the best lobster rolls on the island—freshly shucked, lightly dressed, and served on a buttery bun.
Afternoon Treat: Ice Cream at The Juice Bar
The line outside The Juice Bar is proof of its legendary status. Whether you opt for the homemade waffle cone filled with flavors like Madaket Mystery or classic chocolate, this stop is a must for any foodie.
Dinner: Fine Dining at The Nautilus
Cap off your first day at The Nautilus, an intimate restaurant offering Asian-inspired small plates with an emphasis on local seafood. Try the tuna poke or the scallion pancakes, and don't forget to pair your meal with a creative cocktail.
Day 2: Farm-to-Table Feasts & Sweet Surprises
Breakfast: Brant Point Brunch at Black-Eyed Susan’s
This cozy breakfast spot is a local favorite, serving up classics like lemon ricotta pancakes and huevos rancheros. Arrive early, as they don’t take reservations, and enjoy a meal in one of Nantucket’s most charming spots.
Lunch: Farm-Fresh Bites at Bartlett’s Farm
For a more casual yet delicious lunch, make your way to Bartlett’s Farm, the island’s oldest family-run farm. Grab a freshly made sandwich, a seasonal salad, and a homemade dessert to enjoy as a picnic at a nearby beach.
Afternoon Treat: Macarons & More at Petticoat Row Bakery
Satisfy your afternoon sweet tooth at Petticoat Row Bakery, known for its delicate French macarons, moist cupcakes, and decadent brownies. It’s the perfect place to refuel for the evening ahead.
Dinner: Romantic Waterfront Dining at Cru
Situated right on the harbor, Cru is an upscale seafood hotspot with a glamorous yet relaxed vibe. Order the oysters, indulge in the famous butter-poached lobster, and sip on a glass of champagne as you watch the sunset.
Day 3: Hidden Gems & Local Favorites
Breakfast: Coffee & Pastries at The Corner Table
Start your day with a strong espresso and a warm almond croissant at The Corner Table, a cozy café known for its relaxed ambiance and freshly baked goods.
Lunch: A Classic Island Clambake at The Lobster Trap
For an authentic New England experience, treat yourself to a clambake at The Lobster Trap, where you can enjoy steamers, lobster, and corn on the cob.
Afternoon Treat: Cheese & Wine at Epernay
For a more refined afternoon snack, stop by Epernay Wine & Spirits, a boutique wine shop offering tastings of carefully curated wines. Pair it with a selection of artisanal cheeses from Murray’s Cheese Shop for an elevated experience.
Dinner: Italian Indulgence at Ventuno
End your culinary journey with a delicious Italian feast at Ventuno, a cozy trattoria offering homemade pasta, flavorful seafood dishes, and an impressive wine list. Try the bucatini carbonara or the squid ink pasta for a satisfying final meal on the island.
Final Bites & Takeaways
Before you leave Nantucket, make one last stop at Something Natural for a sandwich to-go, and pick up a loaf of their famous Portuguese bread for the road. If you’re looking for a souvenir, grab a bag of chocolate-covered cranberries from Aunt Leah's Fudge—a little taste of Nantucket to bring home with you.
This three-day foodie itinerary will take you through the best flavors Nantucket has to offer, from fresh seafood to sweet delights. Whether you're a seasoned foodie or just love indulging in delicious meals, Nantucket promises an unforgettable culinary adventure.
What’s your favorite Nantucket food spot? Let me know in the comments! ????️????
